New York Investment Property for Sale - 2024 Rental Home Appreciation

State: New York


The New York City (NYC) real estate market is considered a "gateway" real estate market because of its history of sustained growth, stability, and appreciation.

New York City can be difficult for individual real estate investors and property owners to enter. It has higher prices, property taxes, and closing costs than most markets. Fortunately, it's not impossible to penetrate.

NYC real estate is not as affordable as Chicago, another gateway market, but it's not as expensive as Los Angeles. In fact, three of the city's five boroughs are still relatively affordable for real estate investors and first-time homebuyers.

Real estate investors can find nearly every property type in New York City's property listings. Whether you're interested in investing in a co-op apartment, townhouse, multi-family housing, single-family home, new development, or foreclosure, New York City has a real estate investment opportunity for you.

New York's Attractive Housing Market

Think of NYC real estate; you'll likely envision everything from tiny co-op apartments to luxury condominiums. If you've ever seen Friends or Sex in the City, you may think of supers, subletting, and rent caps. The NYC real estate market is much more diverse than that.

New York City is divided into five unique boroughs for real estate investors to consider. They are Brooklyn, Bronx, Manhattan, Staten Island, and Queens.

  • Brooklyn: Brooklyn is in south NYC and is the city's most populous borough. It's home to Coney Island and the Brooklyn Bridge. It's known for its creative energy, cultural diversity, and delicious pizza. The median listing price in Brooklyn is $900/sqft, and the median sales price is $919,650. The median rent is $3,150/month.
  • The Bronx: The Bronx is in north NYC between Manhattan and Yonkers. It's home to the New York Botanical Garden and Bronx Zoo. The Bronx is known as the cradle of rap and hip hop. It's also one of the most affordable NYC boroughs. It has a lower-than-average purchase price and rent. The median listing price in the Bronx is $342/sqft, and the median sales price is $380,000. The median rent is $2,350/month.
  • Manhattan: Manhattan is in the heart of NYC and is the borough most people think of when they envision the city. Manhattan is known for its many skyscrapers, high-rise apartment buildings, and landmarks like Central Park. The median listing price in Manhattan is $1,520/sqft, and the median sales price is $1,400,000. The median rent is $4,500/month.
  • Staten Island: Staten Island is southwest NYC near the New Jersey state line. It's known as the "Borough of Parks" because it has many green spaces. Like The Bronx, it's one of the city's more affordable neighborhoods with a lower-than-average purchase price and rent. The median listing price in Staten Island is $407/sqft, and the median sales price is $619,000. The median rent is $2,380/month.
  • Queens: Queens is in eastern NYC, south of The Bronx. It's one of NYC's safest and most affordable boroughs and attracts young families. The median listing price in Queens is $542/sqft, and the median sales price is $620,000. The median rent is $2,500/month.

A few other areas of note are Long Island, an urban, densely populated island just east of New York City with plenty of residential property; Tribeca, a neighborhood in west Manhattan along the Hudson River with plenty of new development properties; and the Upper East Side, another Manhattan located along the east side of Central Park with higher property values. No matter what you buy, your New York investment property will generate rental income.

Rental Home Appreciation in New York

New York City is the most populous and densely populated city in the U.S., And it has a robust rental market. Just over 68% of its 20 million residents are renters. That's roughly 13.6 million New Yorkers who need rental properties.

According to Realtor, the median listing price in New York City is $936 per square foot with a median sale price of $878,000. Zillow's Home Value Index reports an 8.2% change since last year. The median rent in New York City is $3,810 per month. The average cap rate for each borough is 3-6%.

New York City presents a lot of opportunities for real estate investors to increase their cash flow and earn passive income.

Economic Growth in New York

The New York City economy is the largest municipal and regional economy in the U.S. It's considered the world's leading financial center and is a global hub for business and commerce.

The city's primary industries include financial services, healthcare, business services, trade, and education. NYC is home to Wall Street, One World Trade Center, and 45 Fortune 500 companies. They include JP Morgan Chase, Verizon Communications, Citigroup, Metlife, Pfizer, and Morgan Stanley. These employers provide stability and jobs that attract new, young professional residents worldwide.

Want to invest in an NYC property? Sign up with Arrived to discover how we make buying investment property easy and affordable.

Empowering the world to build wealth through modern real estate investing.
Browse Arrived Properties